Monday, May 12, 2008

Health

USN Current Issue

2. Find a mentor

Not just a companion, but a trusted medical guide

By Bernadine Healy, M.D
Posted 10/31/04

In the olden days of medicine, it was said you could cure half the sick by putting them into bed and the other half by getting them up. And the doctor always knew which was which, for he (almost always a "he") was the unchallenged voice of authority. Medical decisions followed a straight course.

Today we know more and can do more, and for almost any illness the paths to be taken are more maze than unbending line. Doctors present options and offer preferences; patients are told the decision is theirs. That's good if you believe in patient empowerment. It's hard to feel empowered, though, if you aren't sure which way to go. Several medical studies have shown that many people faced with important medical decisions wished they'd had some help, even in framing the right questions to ask their doctors.

Cindy Sweeting, 46, calls her bout with cancer 15 months ago a journey to a place she had never been before. "I cannot imagine planning a trip for your life where you don't have a guide who has seen it with their own eyes, or maybe even lived there before," says Sweeting, director of equity research at Templeton Investments in Fort Lauderdale, Fla. The sheer number of choices she had to make in a short period of time was overwhelming. Which doctors to see. Lumpectomy or mastectomy. How to balance work and family with rounds of chemotherapy and radiation treatments. And breast reconstruction: Would it be too much to take on after months of heavy-duty cancer therapy, or might it be a kind of closure for Sweeting, the last step in her recovery? "It's hard to make these decisions in a vacuum or based only on what you have read," she says.

Mitzvah. She didn't have to. In her sojourn, she sought and found medically knowledgeable mentors who helped her narrow her options. They offered tips and provided perspective perfectly suited to Sweeting's temperament and personal circumstance. Experienced, knowledgeable, and trusted, they brought her confidence and often an emotional boost.

Mentor was the wizened old man in Greek mythology who guided the son of Odysseus as he set off in search of his father. Mentor was an in-the-background kind of guy. He was there, selflessly, to help with fateful choices. But Mentor had an additional dimension: He was none other than Athena, the goddess of wisdom, who took on the form of Mentor to help Odysseus's son during critical moments of his journey. That image well informs a modern-day medical mentor--wise, experienced, trusted, available, unobtrusive. And every bit as important, a mentor takes on this role out of human kindness and not for personal gain. In a biblical sense, mentoring is a mitzvah, a good deed that is its own reward.

For Sweeting, identifying mentors at different steps along the course of her illness was crucial to her recovery. Suzanne Grimes, a friend from New York City, was a first call. Their friendship went back to their college years. They both had children, close families, and high-octane jobs. And they shared similar views on how to face difficult times. As a breast cancer survivor herself, Grimes had already taken the difficult journey. She handled it with decisiveness and courage, the way Sweeting wanted to. When her first biopsy was negative, she confided in Grimes that she was uneasy about the result. Grimes, who knew how nebulous needle biopsies could be, listened carefully and encouraged her to seek another biopsy. When the diagnosis was handed down, Grimes was there, calm and positive, offering tips on hair and clothes, translating some of the medicalese, and filling Sweeting in on how to balance the cycles of treatments with the demands of her work and the needs of her teenage children.

advertisement

advertisement

Symptom Search

American Hospital Association Symptom Finder

Discover possible causes of your symptoms.

NEWSLETTER

Sign up today for the latest headlines from U.S. News and World Report delivered to you free.

RSS FEEDS

Personalize your U.S. News with our feeds of blogs and breaking news headlines.

USNews MOBILE

U.S. News daily briefings are also available on your mobile device.

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.