Resveratrol and CoQ10 Supplements Are Popular—But Unproven

Reader Comments

Back to article

Completely one sided, ill-informed article. Let's remember who probably pays most of the bills for US News et.al.

Tomas of AR 6:16PM June 12, 2012

'Just wondering why there aren't reliable scientific studies on such popular supplements. Maybe big pharma doesn't want us to know something?

Jorge of OR 12:14PM September 27, 2011

Wow ... the title of this is not only misleading but just plain false. There are far more studies proving the effectiveness of these substances than studies with inconclusive findings. The author even admits that these substances are proven with those who are deficient due to age, disease, or stress inducing conditions. Let's see ... that applies to whom? Everyone eventually. I certainly wouldn't want to be on the wrong end of the karma loop for discouraging use of these helath-enabling substances. Sadly, it seems there's an endless supply of shock-value journalism jockeys who'll do anything to get their little spit to rise to the top.

davea0511 of MD 9:47PM July 14, 2011

I must say that for the last 3 months I have taken the 250 mg version of Resveratrol with active ubiquinol so tHe Converstion is enhanced.( I am over 40) th.e brand I use is named Resvereage and is organic. So far great results.

Paul c. of NC 12:20AM August 04, 2010

As a correction, it was ubiquinone that showed reduction in biomarkers of exercise induced muscle damage in athletes (Kendo athletes).

Sid Shastri of CA 11:38AM March 07, 2010

Decades of research have been done with an ordinary, oxidized form of CoQ10 called ubiquinone. However, recently Japanese scientists made a breakthrough that allowed for commercial forms of ubiquinol (called Kaneka QH) to be produced. Ubiquinol has been studied in athletes, and it has been shown to reduce biomarkers known to correlate with muscle damage. Additionally, QH has been shown to improve edothelial function, thus improving circulation. Those under oxidative stress, i.e. diabetics, have particularly low levels of QH in the body, indicative of loss of correct redox balance.

Bottom Line

I think that Ubiquinol is the way to go for sparking stimulant-free elevations in physical performance, and this is being validated as we speak at University institutions. Ubiquinol is a proven supplement and its benefits are enormous. Give it a try.

Sid Shastri of CA 11:49PM March 06, 2010

I agree with Dr. Simms on Resveratrol. I started my research last year after all the hooplah on the internet and TV. I tried 5 different brands and found one on the internet with 500mg of Trans-resveratrol. I took 2 every day for a month. The other brands came in 100mg some Trans-resveratrol some not. I have to admit I see the benefits in taking this supplement. It may or may not prolong my life, but it did increase my energy, endurance, some weight loss, not to mention my skin and hair. I look younger! A friend saw me last week after one year and she raved about my skin and how young I looked. She made my day. Resveratrol seems to make my systems work more efficiently. Make sure you get at least 500mg of trans-resveratrol a day, if you want to experience any results. I have my own health regime and supplements, but Resveratrol is potentially the most revolutionary discovery I made! Wishing you Health, Wealth, Prosperity and Forever Young:-)

Saquina Akanni of CA 4:11AM February 23, 2010

I became aware of Ubiquinol in July 2009 by reading the literature on CoQ10. I immediately changed from CoQ10 to Ubiquinol and noticed a pronounced improvement in my health and vigor. Most noticeable are improved periodontal health, regeneration of cuticles lost to eczema forty years ago, prevention of athletes foot, increased exercise capacity for intensity but not yet endurance, repair of tendon strain, thicker footpad and finger tip callous, increased production of cerumen. I did a saturation experiment on self. At saturation I get a tingling/numbness in fingertips and toes. I cannot say for certain whether the sensation is more or less sensitivity. My brother and uncle related by mitochondrial inheritance experienced the same. The sensation is reversible with reduced dose for all of us. My formula for dose is to assume production of 500 mg/day at age 26. Expect production to decline by half for every twenty years after age 26. In practice I tolerate 200 mg/day at age 62. I estimate the earliest a person would NOTICE benefit from CoQ10/ubiquinol supplements is age 40-50. Ubiquinol is a boon. However, geriatric patients need many other supplements, and vigorous exercise as well. As a young athlete I was in constant pain from exercise. I now understand that the normal pain from vigorous exercise is necessary to maintain the health of youth. Ubiquinol helps me retain the ability to exert effort and challenge my limits. Ubiquinol does not get me into the gym and out on the running field. CoQ10 studies on athletic performance show no improvement with CoQ10 supplements. The studies all involved trained athletes in the prime of life. Such studies should be repeated with ubiquinol and geriatric athletes if any performance improvement is to be shown. Unfortunately there are not enough geriatric athletes available for study. An acquaintance suffered stroke and paralysis while taking CoQ10. She recovered 100%. The literature documents similar recovery from stroke aided by CoQ10. I estimate her age at 40. She had high blood pressure. Although this is an isolated event my own experience with improved cell proliferation with ubiquinol supplements suggests that ubiquinol should be used to repair brain injury. CoQ10 is documented to improve repair of heart injuries. Repair of joint, tendon injuries, and emphysema are speculative, but I have the notion. Likewise speculative are periodontal bone repair, and immune response to terminal lung infection. For sure I see no improvement in my own presbyopia, a free radical cross link impairment. Ubiquinol improves energy production in old systems. I am reminded of a discussion of automobile improvements with a mechanic. He said everything runs better with more horsepower.

Keith Beatty of CA 5:07AM February 19, 2010

Which drug company's payroll is the author on? I suggest you contact Dr. Beatrice Golumb at the UCSD campus and they 5 year study that she did. She can point you at several others. Your liver produces CoQ10 and as you age produces less, Statins -ALL OF THEM- block the production (I've lived with the results now for over a decade) Ubiquinol is how your body extracts the oxygen from your blood and manufactures ATP (look it up). I also suggest you look up Dr. Duane Graveline (Spacedoc) for further info. -sigh-

John C. Campbell III of MD 4:58PM February 13, 2010

Dr. Oz last week on TV said that he now takes 500mg of Trans-resveratrol every day and further said that because of the recent scientific studies which show many benefits it should be your number one supplement. It may or may not prolong your life, but what is missed by many is that it improves your quality of life now,it increases energy,increases endurance, lowers blood sugar, reduces cholesterol and promotes weightloss without side effects. People also report better sleep and better focus and improved memory. Resveratrol appears to be amakeover for the body making it operate more efficiently. The most consistently recommended by doctors is biotivia transmax or bioforte which is also being used to treat depression. Make sure you get at least 500mg of trans-resveratrol as the cis isomer is useless in the body but is substituted by some manufacturers becasue it is cheaper. Resveratrol is a potentially revolutionary discovery in the supplementation arena.

Dr. Simms of TX 1:24PM February 13, 2010

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Back to article

Eat + Run

advertisement

advertisement