Electronic Medical Records: Will Your Privacy Be Safe?

Reader Comments

Back to blog

I am an RN (Registered Nurse) who works with electronic medical record (EMR) charting in the medical community (a large hospital/health system). I and my colleagues have been discussing the lack of confidentiality for the mentally ill patient with this transparent, rapid, and highly accessable EMR system. In psychiatric and mental health care settings we have worked under strict confidentiality rules to insure that the patient/client relationship could develop trust. It is one thing to share with your family care physician (PCP) that you have a sore throat than to share that you feel depressed and have thoughts of suicide. Yet, any information shared with a physician, or nurse, is transported into the EMR system, consequently, allowing acessabilty to what was believed to be a confidential conversation(s) with one care provider. Unfortunately, in cyber space news,one can read that future employers and future financial lenders could potentially have access to these records when deciding whether to hire, promote or offer loans for these particular clients. For example, a patient who has a history of cancer, cardiac problems, and/ or mental illness, there looms the potential that they could potentially be fired from a job or turned down for a job due to information provided in their medical. They could be judged by a health history that was developed by assessments for problems, or they would not need to be in their PCP's office nor hospitalized. In the EMR you rarely will have an understanding about how the patient is doing after their open heart surgery or suicidal ideation when discharged from the hospital, because technically, the assessed problem has been treated and the patient is sent home. Anyone who reads a EMR will see the portrait of an ill person, not the healthier person who no longer requires medical care. Thus, this is where a major flaw occurs, in allowing almost unlimited access to these records, even for other medical care providers who continue to see a "Problem List" (often without date of occurrence) rather than a dated resolution list of problems. The next time you visit a healthcare provider (PCP) who is using a EMR you will be provided with a copy of your visit providing some very helpful information and some not so helpful, like the time you inquired about Viagra for you know.... well it was a discussion with your PCP whom you have known for twenty years, and later you see Impotency on your EMR Problem List. Yes, not only for you, but for all the other eyes who can now access your ahem... conversations with your PCP. I will end this comment with humor as that is the best medicine until specific treatent can be determined and WE ALL FIND A WAY OUT of this confidentialily mess.

Carol, will this be confidential of OR 11:32AM February 22, 2013

Privacy laws declares fines to all offenders to include neglience. I believe it is necessary to impose even severe penalities when confidentiality is breached or misused to since EMR becoming mandated. Medical professionals entrusted with our lives and medical histories must be held accountable without doubt.

Robert of VA 11:24AM September 20, 2012

I have read about autism research lately where the information linking obesity to autism comes from patient medical records. This seems a huge breach of confidentiality to me. If it were my pregnancy, my obesity, my doctors office supplying that information, I would be shocked to discover this use of my records for this purpose. How can this be legal. I always assumed that everything I said and did in my doctor's office was confidential. Even putting it out as part of research without identifiable markers is still allowing it to be used without my consent by a researcher.

Linda of NH 7:44PM April 08, 2012

Aloha guys! Do you know where I can find more info on this topic?

ways for kids to earn money of AL 8:34PM March 02, 2011

Hey mate! Where can I find more blogs about this?

quick ways to earn money 15 of AL 9:27AM February 26, 2011

I am a medical transcriptionist and I believe that the EMR is basically a way for the government, insurance companies, busybodies, etc to access our most private information. I personally do not want my records online and believe people should have a choice as to whether they want this. We are being railroaded into the EMR by the government, insurance companies, and the companies that sell this technology because they gain from it. Hasn't the latest news about Wikileaks made anyone wake up and see how vulnerable our records will be and that they can and will be hacked into? I want my records kept at my hospital (offline), and doctor's office (offline) only.....and I should have that right. They say quick online access to your medical records could save your life, but I say that is garbage. If a hospital needs your old records, they can contact your hospital/doctor and the info can be faxed without it being online. People need to think about the damage that can be done to them if an insurance company or potential employer can read their private records complete with whether they drink, do drugs, have mental illness, have a lot of medical issues, have a family history of cancer or other major illness, etc. The push for electronic medical records needs to be stopped before we lose our privacy for good.

Mary E. of OH 1:07PM February 02, 2011

Once the Democrats can access anyones health records, they will exploit it by releasing any disparaging information about their Republican opponents. This is absolutely guaranteed to happen. No Democrat can ever be trusted at all. They have a criminal mindset.

Waiting to see of IL 11:05AM October 15, 2010

Hate to tell all the privacy freaks out there..but the VA already has electronic medical records and two of the four doctors that I go to in the private sector are busily converting..to the chagrin of their medical staffs..So Get with it!!!!Your records will be public soon via the electronic records sysytem..I'm sure any hacker can get in to any system..if they want

Bill MOrgan of PA 7:09AM July 22, 2010

Beautiful site!

soma's acacia extraction guide of 5:40PM May 31, 2010

Nice post, thanks for writing!

seolace of AL 9:47PM May 06, 2010

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Back to blog

Heart to Heart

Bernadine Healy, M.D., U.S.News & World Report's health editor and author of the magazine's On Health column, is the former head of the National Institutes of Health, the American Red Cross, and the College of Medicine and Public Health at Ohio State University. A cardiologist and author of two books, she spent more than 25 years practicing medicine. In this blog, she covers matters close to her heart, including cardiovascular disease and other important aspects of personal health and health policy.

advertisement

advertisement