7 Reasons Men Die First
Popular culture may paint men as the stronger sex, but from the moment a boy is born, his life is more likely than his sister's to be cut short. Across national and cultural boundaries, men die an average of seven years earlier than women; the disparity in the United States is approximately five years. In a new book, Why Men Die First, Marianne Legato, a specialist in gender-specific medicine at Columbia University, explains: They're genetically and biologically fragile to start with, she says, and societal norms that encourage and even demand risky behavior by men put them at risk. Still, Legato told U.S. News, men and their families can push back. She highlighted seven reasons why males die prematurely—and seven actions they can take to prolong their time.
1. Males are burdened with natural genetic deficits.
While every cell in a woman's body has two large X chromosomes, men have one X and one smaller Y chromosome; the Y is half the size. The "spare" X chromosomes allow women's bodies to compensate when faced with damage in ways that men's cells cannot. In addition, mutations are three to six times more likely in a Y chromosome than an X chromosome. This genetic deficit could be part of the reason why miscarriages, infections, birth defects, cancers, and many other health problems strike males especially hard.
2. The womb is more treacherous for boys.
Baby boys are one-and-a-half to two times more likely to die at birth than girls. A weaker immune system, a tendency for immature lung development, inadequate blood flow to male fetuses, and high vulnerability to maternal stresses seem to be the culprits. Brain hemorrhages, congenital malformations, pneumonia, and urinary tract infections are all more common among male newborns.
3. Males are more likely to have developmental disorders.
An article published in the British Medical Journal notes that a variety of disorders—including reading delays, deafness, autism, ADHD, blindness, seizure disorders, hyperactivity, clumsiness, stammering, and Tourette's syndrome are three to four times more common in boys than girls. There are 10 males for every female with Asperger's syndrome, a mild form of autism.
4. They're biologically more prone to risky behavior.
Slower development of the area of the brain that governs judgment makes males—especially adolescents—more likely than girls to die in accidents. According to a National Safety Council statistics, males were involved in 82 percent of accidental deaths associated with firearms, 87 percent of bicycle-related fatalities, nearly double the number of poisoning deaths, and almost four times as many homicides in 2004. Likewise, in 2006 they were in 81 percent of fatal crashes involving drunken driving.
5. A "suck-it-up" culture means men often languish with depression.
Although women are more likely to make suicide attempts, the ratio of men to women who actually kill themselves is nearly 4 to 1. For men ages 20 to 24, fully 15 percent of all deaths are suicides.
6. Men choose more dangerous occupations.
The bulk of sailors, firefighters, police officers, construction workers, and farmers are men. Of the 5,734 fatalities that occurred on the job in 2005, men were the victims in the vast majority—5,328. And men still do the vast majority of the fighting during military conflicts.
7. Coronary artery disease strikes men early.
Estrogen seems to protect women from heart disease until they are well into midlife, but it is common for symptoms to begin in men by the age of 35. Making matters worse, men have naturally low levels of protective HDL cholesterol. The result: Between 70 percent and 89 percent of all sudden cardiac events occur in men, and men die three times more frequently of coronary artery disease than women.
Seven Things Men Can Do to Lengthen Their Lives
1. Know your blood pressure no matter what your age; exercise vigorously every day to increase your naturally low HDL levels; and start getting screened for coronary artery disease in your twenties.
2. Go to the doctor and tell him or her if you're having a health problem of any kind. Our culture may reward stoic behavior from men; disease does not. This is especially true for men who feel sad or depressed for extended periods. It is extremely common for men to internalize and ignore their problems. Seek help.
3. Monitor your behavior and minimize tendencies to act in a boneheaded way. You know better than to drive recklessly, ignore safety protocols at work, or operate machinery while intoxicated.
4. Keep off excess weight to avoid a phalanx of chronic diseases that will impair your quality of life well before they actually kill you. Coronary artery disease, diabetes, and prostate cancer are a few extremely common risks associated with being overweight that typically take a toll on your well-being—including the ability to have an erection—long before life is actually cut short. In some cases, it's the disease itself that causes the sexual problems; in others it's the medications or surgeries used to treat the disease that take the toll.
5. Don't smoke. According to the American Cancer Society, smokers who quit at age 35 can expect to live up to eight and a half years longer than continuing smokers. Risk begins to fall within months and falls to the levels of nonsmokers in three to five years.
6. Don't fear digital rectal exams. PSA screening for prostate cancer is controversial because it might pick up tiny cancers that aren't clinically important, but there's little doubt that digital exams reveal dangerous cancers that have to be treated. Same goes for colonoscopies. They're uncomfortable, yes, but far less so than malignant colon cancer and chemotherapy.
7. Protect your head, and tell your doctor if you get dinged especially hard. A CT scan may be needed. Concussions may seem harmless, but they can cause long-term brain bleeding that lead to memory problems, disrupted sleep, and personality changes that last a lifetime.
Tags: aging | men's health | longevity
Tools:
Share
|
| Comments (10) | Print
Reader Comments
mens health
I think mens health is largely determined by their family history and their living habits.
This is a joke
Your doctor's opinion is little more than politically correct rhetoric founded on pseudoscience. You should be ashamed of yourself. Your genetic analysis is just plain incorrect. I'm not even a doctor, I just took biology in college, and I know you're wrong. Your attempt to justify behavioral difference based on areas of the brain that are barely understood is little more than pandering to the female audience that likely predominates the health section of your website. Your professionalism borders at the level of the modern sitcom, complete with the buffoon husband and the brilliant wife that consistently denigrates him.
I agree with the other posters. Men's health is worse than women's because there is less concern for it, both in the medical community and society as a whole. When that changes, men's health will improve.
Also, the three leading causes of preventable death are obesity, smoking, and excessive drinking in that order. Women lead men in obesity and smoking rates and have for over a decade. It is well known by the medical community (but apparently not by you) that women aren't in any better health than men, it's just that the disease men face are deadlier earlier in their lives. Yet still, as others have posted, men have no special interests groups to support their needs while women are federally funded.
So the way you're blaming men for their health is really just another way of blaming the victim. In this case you're in the OK because you're attacking men and you know you'll get little retaliation by doing so thanks to political correctness run amok.
Interesting points from many
I would have to agree with the poster from Texas regarding much of the pseudo science that has taken hold at the graduate level in medicine. It's easy for people to hear buzzwords and take them as gospel truth when more research needs to be conducted.
Ultimately, men need more resources. There are federally sponsored health organizations for women that have no male counterpart. An example is the FDA
(http://www.fda.gov/womens/default.htm ) clearly this is a womens health site.
The Men's health site is a minor link on the page on the left hand side off of the womens site! (http://www.4woman.gov/mens/ ) There is no men's health page at DHHS or the FDA. Where is the 4men dot gov? (2) see Reference
The call for intellectual honesty is well received. If we are to be truly intellectually honest we must admit we can't have it both ways; You can't say on one hand, that women are neglected by the medical establishment and that they are aways victims hence the need for their own hospitals, government funded websites etc. etc. yet on the same hand say, women are biologically superior.
If the female sex is so biologically superior, then why the need for all of the special health care and social support?
While I'm sure Marianne Legato's intentions are good, they have a succinct ring of selective Eugenics (1) See reference
Ultimately both sexes are prone to specific medical issues that are unique to them. Let's leave the social-political stuff on the amateur blogs where it belongs and leave the real science to those of us who really wish to find the cause, affect and effective treatment of disease processes that affect both sexes.
References:
1. http://www.eugenicsarchive.org/eugenics/ [Human Genome Project]
2. http://www.fda.gov/womens/default.htm [ Food and Drug Administration - Office of
Women's Health ]
3. http://www.4woman.gov/mens/ [Men's health page on 4Women ]
advertisement






