Saturday, November 28, 2009

Health

On Health and Money Blog -- U.S. News & World Report

Rape Victims Can Be Hurt Financially, Too

February 21, 2008 05:32 PM ET | Michelle Andrews | Permanent Link | Print

Reader Comments

It is insane and immoral that this is still going on. BOTH Presidential candidates come from areas that do or did this. Palin's town actually started doing it when she was still mayor and they had to pass a law banning it because of her.

It is totally unethical to do this to rape victims. There is no reason, in the 21st century, why they cannot simply stop this practice. All it would do is discourage people from coming forward.

Could the reason be another issue altogether?

I read an article online in the Anchorage Daily News yesterday, where a local reader commented that the reason Palin resisted shifting the financial burden of the rape kits to the police department budget was because at the end of the exam, the rape victim is offered EMERGENCY CONTRACEPTION.

Does anyone know if this is the case or standard in police rape kits? Given Governor Palin's stated opposition to a woman's right to an abortion cases of rape or incest, this certainly seems like a valid reason and an important issue to research.

Illinois not charging thanks to Obama

Please see the information provided here:

http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2008/9/9/124815/2904/672/592233

Reply to Female of FL

This is very relevant. We have a 72-year old presidential candidate who would be 80 by the end of his second term. There is a very real possibility that the VP would be president. I too, am a female, originally from FL, but I have a very different take on what Palin's policies as Mayor have on the election. Unfortunately, this and her couple of years as governor are all we can really know about how she would lead our nation. I find making the victim pay for a rape kit sickening. It goes right along with learning that she fired a librarian for not removing "morally objectionable" literature from the library. She seems to represent all that was wrong with the past- putting the victim on trial, deciding what is right and wrong for society. I am not sorry for being outraged for the practice of making the victim pay and letting it influence my voting decision.

compensate victim of rape kits and palin

Has anyone noticed that this is a national election at a time when the economy is in trouble, the public is being required to bail out private companies because they are "too big to allow to go under"--or that Russia is planning to move weapons into

Venezuela, or that there is a war on and an international terror movement out to get us, we are overrun with illegal labor that is driving down the number of , and pay for, jobs --by the millions --for citizens, etc.

Of course there ought to be compensation for rape victims. But a national election ought not to turn on what may have been the law in the VICE presidential candidate's town during her terms as mayor.

Of course, if we keep up this focus we can ignore all of the discussions about the actual presidential candidates that may shed some light on who they really are and on how the country will fare under each with respect to the earth shaking issues of the day.

Rape, what's the point???

I was raped March 16 2008. My husband was the one who called 911. I was rushed to the hospital. I endured a timely exam, a million questions and multiple stitches. I was out of work for 4 weeks, which was unpaid, because mental state is not considered a short term disability claim. So with income for a month, and I now have a $3700.00 ER visit that I am responsable for. Also the co pays for my doctor's and the every 3 month lab work and exams are my responability too. I am not only ashamed, but baffled on how this is mine to take care of. I undestand for the first time in my life why so many women don't report rape. I was also mistreated, ignored, jugde by law enforcement. Eventually the detective for my case was too busy, short staff, and tired of my calls. That my case was sent to the DA's incomplete. Where it was denied. But, I was told after they weren't going to take my case further, that I am more welcome to write a letter to the DA about their descion. I am so embarassed of our Criminal Justice System, and Health Care Providers, THIS MAKES ME SICK. Pretty much I feel at this point. Why should rape be a crime? If it is such an inconvinance for others.

Dysfuntional Sytem

I was raped march 2nd 2008. I just now recieved my bill, estimating a total cost of 2,ooo dollars, that I DONT have. I never wanted to go to the hospital in the first place, but it was well advised by close friends,( who picked me up from the scene where i was left ). Reluctlantly I went and even after all the horror, I have to look at a bill that will inevitably be hanging over me for many years to come. I did the right thing by turning this case in and I got slapped in the face by my own state. I give my state taxes every year and this is how I am thanked.. Chanrging victims MUST stop--for our sanity alone, but evenmore so it is disgracingly and morally WRONG!

Rape Victims

I was raped in 2004. I was so ashamed of the whole incident I didn't want to report it, but did with the coaxing of friends. Thank god. But then the exam was horrible. The doctors and nurses were harsh and cold. They acted like I was inconveniencing them. Never mind that I was a scared 20 year old. Before they even administered the exam they tried to collect insurance information or informed me that I would have to pay for the entire thing out of pocket. This is a world class hospital with University affiliation. Yet this is the treatment a 20 year old rape victim/student/ local resident received. It is no wonder that women do not want to report this. Especially any woman without health insurance. The entire incident was emotionally exhausting and financially draining. Without insurance i would have been billed $1500. They got there money. It seems it was all they wanted in the first place.

rape victims

As a health-care worker of 15 years, and a student of Criminal Justice this makes my heart race. Women should never be charged a dime for a rape kit or any forensic evidence to be processed. Our goal is not to punish the victim financially but to gain access to the truth. Besides being ashamed, fear of retaliation to them or their loved ones for reporting the crime, NOW THEY HAVE TO PAY THE BILL! I encourage all women to write their local congressmen and stand up not only for women's rights but all victim's rights.

rape victims

I was raped when I was sixteen &am still only seventeen. But even i agree this charging people to pay for the kit is outrageous. The people who need the kits done are already ashamed of what happened to them; they do not need a financial bill to remind them of it. Women who get raped did not ask for it. We said NO & STOP; males did not listen, so we get stuck with the charge? This is ridiculous.

Add your thoughts

All comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

About On Health and Money

Senior Writer Michelle Andrews reports on how to be a smart health consumer and get the best care for your money. Write to her at onhealthmoney@usnews.com.

Health Check

advertisement

NEWSLETTER

Sign up today for the latest headlines from U.S. News & World Report delivered to you free.

RSS FEEDS

Personalize your U.S. News with our feeds of blogs and breaking news headlines.

U.S. NEWS MOBILE

U.S. News daily briefings are also available on your mobile device.

People who read this also read ...

Featured Video

Weight Loss Tips

Put your kitchen on a diet before starting your own weight loss plan.

Flu Symptoms & Prevention

Learn about the virus, and how to prevent and treat it.

Common Sleep Problems

Learn what happens inside our bodies when we get some shut-eye.

Birth Control Methods

Learn about condoms, diaphragms, and other barrier methods of birth control.

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.
Make USNews.com your home page.